Claims
All claims should be reported as soon as possible. Every attempt should be made to protect and preserve property. Many companies prefer that their insureds notify them directly.
We have provided a list of those companies and their phone numbers for your convenience.
Please choose the appropriate policy type below:
Personal Insurance Policy» Business Insurance Policy»You can also notify our agency at 716.937.9196 or 800.343.3890.
| Travelers One Tower Square • Hartford, CT 06183 • 1 (800)252-4633 |
|
| Hartford One Hartford Plaza • Hartford, CT 06155 • 1(800)243-5860 |
|
| Allstate 2775 Sanders Road • Northbrook, IL 60062 • 1(800)255-7828 |
|
| Tower 120 Broadway 31st Floor • New York, NY 10271 • 1(888)856- 5522 |
|
| Preferred Mutual 1 Preferred Way • New Berlin, NY 13411 • 1(800)333-7642 |
|
| New York Central 1899 Central Plaza East • Edmeston, NY 13335 • 1-888-234-6926 |
|
| A Central 1899 Central Plaza East Suite 2000 • Edmeston, New York 13335-1898 • 1-866-222-2242 |
|
| Progressive 6300 Wilson Mills Road • Mayfield Village, Ohio 44143 • 1-800-PROGRESSIVE |
|
| Foremost 5600 Beach Tree Lane • Caledonia, MI 49316 • 1-800-527-3907 |
|
| GMAC P.O. Box 47009 • Oak Park, Michigan 48237 • 1-800-468-3466 |
|
| Erie & Niagara 8800 Sheridan Drive, Box 9062 • Williamsville, NY 14231-9062 PLEASE CALL ELWOOD JORDANS AGENCY FOR ASSISTANCE |
|
| Allegany Co-op 9 N Branch Rd • Cuba, NY 14727-9290 • 1( 800)333.1679 |
|
| RLI 9025 N. Lindbergh Drive • Peoria, IL 61615 • 1(800)444-0406 |
|
| Met Life 200 Park Avenue, • New York, NY 10166 • 1-800-854-6011 |
|
| AM Collectors 496 Kings Hwy. North • Cherry Hill, NJ 08034 • 1-800-360-2277 |
|
| Genesee Patrons 218 East Main Street • Batavia, New York 14020-2282 • 1(800) 343-6496 |
|
| Haggerty 141 River’s Edge Drive, #200 • Traverse City, MI 49684-3265 • 1-800-922-4050 |
|
| National Grange Mutual 55 West Street, • Keene, NH 03431 • 1(877)425-2467 |
|
| Utica First 5981 Airport Road • Oriskany, NY 13424 • 1-800-456-4556 |
| Travelers One Tower Square • Hartford, CT 06183 • 1(800)238-6225 |
|
| Hartford One Hartford Plaza • Hartford, CT 06155 • 1-800-327-3636 |
|
| Allstate 2775 Sanders Road • Northbrook, IL 60062 • 1(800)255-7828 |
|
| Tower 120 Broadway • 31st Floor, New York, NY 10271 • 1(888)856- 5522 |
|
| Preserver 120 Broadway, 31st Floor • New York, NY 10271 • 1(877)883-6599 |
|
| Preferred Mutual 1 Preferred Way • New Berlin, NY 13411 • 1(800)333-7642 |
|
| Zurich 1400 American Lane • Schaumburg, IL 60196 • 1 (800) 987-3373 |
|
| Progressive 6300 Wilson Mills Road • Mayfield Village, Ohio 44143 • 1-800-PROGRESSIVE |
|
| Foremost 5600 Beach Tree Lane • Caledonia, MI 49316 • 1-800-527-3907 |
|
| GMAC P.O. Box 47009 • Oak Park, Michigan 48237 • 1-800-468-3466 |
|
| Erie & Niagara 8800 Sheridan Drive, Box 9062 • Williamsville, NY 14231-9062 PLEASE CALL ELWOOD JORDANS AGENCY FOR ASSISTANCE |
|
| Allegany Co-op 9 N Branch Rd • Cuba, NY 14727-9290 • 800.333.1679 |
|
| RLI 9025 N. Lindbergh Drive • Peoria, IL 61615 • 1(800)444-0406 |
|
| First Rehabilitation 600 Northern Blvd. • Great Neck, NY 11021 • 1(800)-365-4999 |
|
| Genesee Patrons 218 East Main Street • Batavia, New York 14020-2282 • 1(800) 343-6496 |
|
| National Grange Mutual 55 West Street, • Keene, NH 03431 • 1(877)425-2467 |
|
| Utica First 5981 Airport Road • Oriskany, NY 13424 • 1-800-456-4556 |








